Check your ‘canaries’ to keep risk tolerance down

Risk tolerance should be a constant value, but it is often just an attitude or priority, and work priorities change.

If you hear excuses such as “we didn’t know that, we didn’t see that, this is not normal”, be worried that risk tolerance is rising. If you hear excuses like “this is how we work, never had a problem, can’t do everything by the book”, be afraid, for risk tolerance had changed.

When I started working as a metallurgist at BHP in Newcastle, NSW, Australia steelworks in 1980, one of the first departments I was assigned to was the blast furnace. This was a high risk work area and people have died there.

In those days one of the occupational classifications at the steelworks was that of a gas watcher, who carried around a cage and occasionally cleaned it. In it was a yellow canary. If the bird fell of the perch, emergency evacuations followed.

It was meant to detect gases such as carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide and methane. The songful bird would stop singing as an early warning.

One of my tasks each morning was to visit the Stove Cabin (control room) of each of the four blast furnaces and collect the monitoring records of the previous evening. In each Stove Cabin, just to the left of the door, was a cage with a little yellow canary.

These birds did not have a “watcher” assigned to them, but everyone checked in on them. One morning between Christmas and New Year 1980 I entered the Stove Cabin after the shift foreman. He came barreling out past me, almost knocking me over.

“Clear off! The bird!” I followed his lead and ran for it. The canary was lying feet up in the cage. It turned out to be a rare false alarm. How many canaries do you need at work?

Frogs do not respond
Another behavioural type is more common at work; frogs. You have all heard the story. If you place a frog in tepid water and slowly bring it to boil, the frog will at first delay jumping out, until it no longer can jump.

We do not notice if the environment slowly becomes toxic, approaching deadly. How many frogs do you have at work? Risk tolerance itself is a toxic process.

I have lost count of the Transformational Safety Culture walkabouts I have conducted and mentioned a potential hazard to my host. In at least two thirds of these situations the response is “didn’t know” or “didn’t see”.

Some of these hazards or risks have been significant; uncovered or unlabelled confined spaces, working at height using visibly frayed or cut fall protection equipment, and so on.

Another common response to management is “defending the frog”. When we conduct quantitative Safety Culture Reviews, among the common responses are various kinds of denial.

I hear stuff like “that can’t be right, we would have seen it or felt it”. You may find that over half of your workforce acknowledge multiple shortcuts, but their autonomic response is “no, that can’t be happening, that is not normal”. These are the frogs croaking.

Seek out fore-warnings of risk tolerance. Forewarned can be forearmed. Watch and listen to your canaries on site. Conduct an empirical analysis of the safety culture functioning beneath the surface of your workplace.

David G Broadbent is a safety psychologist and founder of TransformationalSafety.Com, based in Australia, with clients in SA and Asia.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
The following two tabs change content below.
The Creator of the Worlds foremost Safety Culture Improvement Systems.

2 thoughts on “Check your ‘canaries’ to keep risk tolerance down

  1. Hi David, I enjoyed your article. We need the canaries and the frogs, but sometimes these canaries and frogs complain more about non-safety things, like why does the company not wash their overalls for them, than actually coming to management with genuine health and safety problems.
    Trying to get certain people to understand that safety is looking after yourself and others around you and not about getting as much out of the company as you can (eg washing of overalls) does not always sink in.
    Like the saying, you can lead a horse to water but you can’t make it drink. You can give someone training but it does not always make them safety conscious, or dare I say, care.

  2. Trevorlynne – Have you ever tried liviong in a shack with a tap for running water and then washing you clothes too? Many industries wash their staff’s clothing – actually I think are very clever – better hygiene – looking after staff’s health and the hygiene of the product – no man, i fink employers must stop treating their employees like slaves – yes, slaves wages, means obviously the staff will look for ways to supplement their incomes. But if they are happy, they will be productive and loyal – of course their must be discipline, but if they value their job and contribution to society, life will get better for all, not just the fat cats skimming huge profits off the top?

Comments are closed.

Facebook IconLinkedInLinkedInLinkedIn
error: Contact the Cygma Group for Copyright licence.